Hello,
I have been collecting parts and getting parts made for two MG34/41's for going on six years. I am nearly done. One will probably become a dealer sample and the other will become either a dummy gun or a semi-auto. Which one would have more value to a buyer? This is new territory for me.
Michaelangelo
Value Question
-
michaelangelo
- Stabsunteroffizier
- Posts: 51
- Joined: Fri Jun 01, 2007 10:06 am
- Location: Indiana, USA
-
42rocker
- Administrator
- Posts: 3251
- Joined: Fri Jan 11, 2008 6:03 pm
- Anti-spam: Mg42
- Location: Florida
Re: Value Question
nearly done, well you have been working on this project hard for a while now. Congrats on getting to the end to even think about this question. I just bought a dummy mg34 receiver knowning that with very little work I can change it back into a working mg34. Change out of receiver.
That said to yours I would hate to see you make it into a permanent dummy. I would try to offer in any other way as you know how rare the parts are.
Later 42rocker
That said to yours I would hate to see you make it into a permanent dummy. I would try to offer in any other way as you know how rare the parts are.
Later 42rocker
-
www.Prussia.us
- General
- Posts: 1060
- Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2008 7:17 pm
Re: Value Question
I agree w/ 42Rocker, Congrats on your efforts.
That said, when looking for value it depends on the buyer. There are far more buyers that can pay the price for a dummy, than that for a semi. I do not think Centerfire has moved too many TNW semi's recently, granted yours is different but it is a smaller market than a dummy. However if the receiver can easily be made a semi, then take the chance and get a better return on your money. It would be a shame to dummy the receiver, but you do what you have to do.
That said, when looking for value it depends on the buyer. There are far more buyers that can pay the price for a dummy, than that for a semi. I do not think Centerfire has moved too many TNW semi's recently, granted yours is different but it is a smaller market than a dummy. However if the receiver can easily be made a semi, then take the chance and get a better return on your money. It would be a shame to dummy the receiver, but you do what you have to do.
“… corporations have been enthroned, and an era of corruption in high places will follow, … until all wealth is aggregated in a few hands and the Republic is destroyed.”
- Abraham Lincoln (Republican), Nov. 21, 1864
- Abraham Lincoln (Republican), Nov. 21, 1864
-
michaelangelo
- Stabsunteroffizier
- Posts: 51
- Joined: Fri Jun 01, 2007 10:06 am
- Location: Indiana, USA
Re: Value Question
Hello,
It will look a little better than this when it is done.
Michaelangelo
It will look a little better than this when it is done.
Michaelangelo
Re: Value Question
Knowing the parts-sets that I sold you a few years ago......then looking at "today's" market (not 5-6 years ago, nor what the future could bring) my thoughts are:
1: You may be able to sell the Dealer-Sample at about $5k-$6k.......but it's a very limited market, and will probably sit on the market for a year (or more.).
Basing this on sales of C&R Transferable MG34s (I had to take a price-hit on the sale of my C&R MG34 a few years ago, and TNW semi-only sales where the market may be stationary at this point due to lack of "Hobby-Funds" availability.
2: The semi-only model will probably have a same effect on the market.......you can only pull the trigger so fast, and then guys look at a registered FA MG34.
Add about $1,000 to the price of a semi-only TNW SA34 for it being an MG34S or MG34/41 (but semi-only........and this many/may not cover the costs of making the semi-only receiver.....(?). The other "down-side" is that some of the parts such as the bolt will have to be "cut" to make into a semi-only bolt....this brings down their collector-value.
3: Your MG34/41 Lafette will play into the sale(s) somewhere along the line........there were far fewer of them made than standard MG34 Lafettes. The problem here is that I looked into the possibility of using (or making the trigger-parts) an MG42 trigger-assembly from a Yugo-Lafette.....very similar as far as looks and could be modified.
Challanges (Problems) that you will face are available funds on your end to make the required parts/assemblies........challanges on the other end will be available funds for the buyers.
Another "option" is to sell-back the Parts-Sets, Spare-Parts, newly made parts, Lafette, to me (adding in a slight "premium" for doing some of the work/searching that I didn't get a chance to do)...(?)
My contact for your offer is :
Blanksguy2001@chartermi.net.
Regards, RichardS in MI.
US Army, Retired
Blanksguy2001@chartermi.net
1: You may be able to sell the Dealer-Sample at about $5k-$6k.......but it's a very limited market, and will probably sit on the market for a year (or more.).
Basing this on sales of C&R Transferable MG34s (I had to take a price-hit on the sale of my C&R MG34 a few years ago, and TNW semi-only sales where the market may be stationary at this point due to lack of "Hobby-Funds" availability.
2: The semi-only model will probably have a same effect on the market.......you can only pull the trigger so fast, and then guys look at a registered FA MG34.
Add about $1,000 to the price of a semi-only TNW SA34 for it being an MG34S or MG34/41 (but semi-only........and this many/may not cover the costs of making the semi-only receiver.....(?). The other "down-side" is that some of the parts such as the bolt will have to be "cut" to make into a semi-only bolt....this brings down their collector-value.
3: Your MG34/41 Lafette will play into the sale(s) somewhere along the line........there were far fewer of them made than standard MG34 Lafettes. The problem here is that I looked into the possibility of using (or making the trigger-parts) an MG42 trigger-assembly from a Yugo-Lafette.....very similar as far as looks and could be modified.
Challanges (Problems) that you will face are available funds on your end to make the required parts/assemblies........challanges on the other end will be available funds for the buyers.
Another "option" is to sell-back the Parts-Sets, Spare-Parts, newly made parts, Lafette, to me (adding in a slight "premium" for doing some of the work/searching that I didn't get a chance to do)...(?)
My contact for your offer is :
Blanksguy2001@chartermi.net.
Regards, RichardS in MI.
US Army, Retired
Blanksguy2001@chartermi.net
-
michaelangelo
- Stabsunteroffizier
- Posts: 51
- Joined: Fri Jun 01, 2007 10:06 am
- Location: Indiana, USA
Re: Value Question
Richard,
Thank you for your thoughts. You have a great day. I have a Class 2 maufacturer lined up. I will film when I shoot it and post it so you can see it.
MIchaelangelo
Thank you for your thoughts. You have a great day. I have a Class 2 maufacturer lined up. I will film when I shoot it and post it so you can see it.
MIchaelangelo
-
42rocker
- Administrator
- Posts: 3251
- Joined: Fri Jan 11, 2008 6:03 pm
- Anti-spam: Mg42
- Location: Florida
Re: Value Question
Something else to think about with the amount of work that you have done collect those parts.
Please look at a pic that I just took of my new MG34 setup. It has a dummy receiver. Which given about 1 minute I can switch out and make into a semi or (lots of money) Full Auto. Just changing the receiver.
I'm hoping to follow the pirate lead and re-weld a semi later but for now.
Later 42rocker
Please look at a pic that I just took of my new MG34 setup. It has a dummy receiver. Which given about 1 minute I can switch out and make into a semi or (lots of money) Full Auto. Just changing the receiver.
I'm hoping to follow the pirate lead and re-weld a semi later but for now.
Later 42rocker